Evidence of Title
There are different kinds of evidence of Title to Policy moneys. The simplest of these are Nomination and Assignment effected as per Sections 39 and 38 respectively of the Insurance Act, 1938.
Nomination
Nomination under Section 39 is naming of a person or persons to give a valid discharge to the insurance company and receive policy moneys in case of death of life assured during the period of the policy.
Nominee can only receive the moneys. In case of survival of the life assured till the date of maturity, nomination will be ineffective. Nomination can be done by making suitable entries in the proposal to the policy in which case it will be incorporated in the text of the policy.
Nomination can be done only by a Policyholder under a Policy on his own life and not otherwise.
Nomination can be done in favour of one or more persons. But those nominees who are alive on the date of death of the life assured only will receive the policy moneys. For this reason, while nominating more than one person, the life assured should not indicate shares of the policy moneys for individual nominees.
Nomination can be in favour of a minor, in which case, the life assured can appoint an appointee to receive policy moneys on behalf of the minor nominee in case of the death of the life assured during the minority of the nominee and before date of maturity.
Nomination once made can be changed by the life assured at his will (i.e. without any consent from the nominee) at any time but before the policy matures for payment.
Nomination once made is automatically cancelled by (1) cancellation/further change of nomination (2) assignment in favour of a third party—in case assignment is done in favour of the insurance company for a loan out of surrender value of the policy, then nomination will not get cancelled (3) a Will. .
Nomination should be normally in favour of someone near and dear. If a stranger is named as a nominee, there may be a suspicion of absence of insurable interest.
In a Joint Life Policy, normally there is no need for nomination because, in case of death of one life, policy moneys become payable to the surviving life. However there can be a joint nomination providing for a particular contingency, viz the simultaneous death of both lives in a common calamity.
Nomination is an instrument, the insurance law created, to secure an immediate payment of the policy moneys by the insurer, without prejudice to the decision on the question as to who are entitled to succeed the estate of the deceased life assured. Proceeds of the policy do not vest in the nominee though they are payable to the nominee in the event of the death of the holder of the policy. They do not, by virtue of nomination under Section 39 alone, become a part of nominee’s estate before or after the policy matures
Assignment
Assignment of a policy of life insurance, under Section 38 of Insurance Act, 1938, is a transfer of the property contained in the policy by the assignor to the assignee. Unlike a nominee under Section 39, Assignee under Section 38 has all rights under the policy not only to receive the policy moneys when they are due but also to deal with the policy in any way he desires without the consent of the assignor.
To assign a policy, the assignor should be the holder i.e. owner of the policy. It means that the policy need not be on his life. It also means that a person who is an assignee under a policy of life insurance can further assign it to any other person, for which act he need not obtain the consent or concurrence of the original assignor. However, the assignor should not be a minor. A child cannot, during his minority, therefore, assign a policy on his life to another.
Assignee can be anybody including a minor. In case of death of the assignee, the property will devolve upon his/her legal successors. There can be more than one assignee. In case of the death of any one or more assignees, the policy moneys will have to be paid to the legal heirs of the deceased assignee/assignees.
Sub-section (1) of Section 38 of Insurance Act, 1938 mentions that an assignment can be made ‘whether with or without consideration’. But all assignments without consideration are not valid. Assignment for natural love and affection between parties standing in the near relation to each other is valid. But in any other case absence of consideration may render the assignment invalid.
Both absolute and conditional assignments are recognized under the Act. An absolute assignment transfers to the assignee all right, title and interest of the assignor in the policy to the assignee. The policy vests in the assignee absolutely and forms part of his/her death. A conditional assignment also creates an immediate vested interest in the assignee but such interest is liable to be divested on the happening of the contingencies set out in the assignment